HN 日本語サマリー

← 一覧へ戻る
AI・機械学習

ClaudeのAskUserQuestion: 「60秒応答なし – 回答なしで続行」

Claude's AskUserQuestion: "No response after 60s – continued without an answer" (github.com)

13 pointsby tubignaaso10 コメント

要約

Claudeのコードリポジトリで報告された重大なバグは、AskUserQuestionツールが60秒のタイムアウト後にユーザーの応答を待たずに「最善の判断で続行」というデフォルトメッセージを返してしまうことです。これは、AIがユーザーの明示的な確認なしに行動する可能性があり、安全チェックを迂回するため、「極めて危険」とされています。

全文翻訳

Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page. anthropics / claude-code Public Notifications You must be signed in to change notification settings Fork 21.8k Star 135k [BUG] **EXTREME DANGER**: AskUserQuestion: "No response after 60s — continued without an answer" #73125New issueCopy linkNew issueCopy linkOpenOpen[BUG] **EXTREME DANGER**: AskUserQuestion: "No response after 60s — continued without an answer"#73125Copy linkAssignees Labelsapi:bedrockIssue relates to AWS BedrockIssue relates to AWS Bedrockarea:toolsarea:tuibugSomething isn't workingSomething isn't workingplatform:linuxIssue specifically occurs on LinuxIssue specifically occurs on Linuxplatform:vscodeIssue specifically occurs in VS CodeIssue specifically occurs in VS CodeDescriptionANoginopened on Jul 2, 2026Issue body actionsPreflight Checklist I have searched existing issues and this hasn't been reported yet This is a single bug report (please file separate reports for different bugs) I am using the latest version of Claude Code What's Wrong? ● Claude asked: ⎿ ·[...] ● No response after 60s — continued without an answer [...] ❯ What is this No response after 60s — continued without an answer?????????? ● Direct answer: that line came from the AskUserQuestion tool itself, not from you. When I posed the three-part question ([...]), the tool call sat unanswered for 60 seconds and the harness returned this verbatim: ▎ "No response after 60s — the user may be away from keyboard. Proceed using your best judgment based on the context so far; you can ▎ re-ask this question later if it's still relevant." So the mechanism is: AskUserQuestion has a 60-second timeout; if no selection arrives, it auto-returns that "proceed with best judgment" result instead of blocking. I did not fabricate or skip anything — that's what the tool handed back. [...] ❯ Is this a tool parameter? ● No — it is not. I've just checked the AskUserQuestion schema I was given: its parameters are questions, answers, annotations, metadata. There is no timeout parameter, no "60s", nothing about response timing. I passed no such parameter, and none exists to pass. What Should Happen? Not this!!! AskUserQuestion is an explicit safety check and I have rules and hooks to make sure the right questions are asked and that scary things do not happen without my input. Suddenly Claude is told to "proceed with best judgment"? What?! Error Messages/Logs Steps to Reproduce No idea. Claude Model Opus Is this a regression? Yes, this worked in a previous version Last Working Version 2.1.196 (I am guessing) Claude Code Version 2.1.198 Platform AWS Bedrock Operating System Other Linux Terminal/Shell VS Code integrated terminal Additional Information Nothing in https://code.claude.com/docs/en/changelog to even alert about this!!!Reactions are currently unavailableMetadataMetadataAssigneesThariqSLabelsapi:bedrockIssue relates to AWS BedrockIssue relates to AWS Bedrockarea:toolsarea:tuibugSomething isn't workingSomething isn't workingplatform:linuxIssue specifically occurs on LinuxIssue specifically occurs on Linuxplatform:vscodeIssue specifically occurs in VS CodeIssue specifically occurs in VS CodeTypeNo typeFieldsNo fields configured for issues without a type.ProjectsNo projectsMilestoneNo milestoneRelationshipsNone yetDevelopmentNo branches or pull requestsIssue actionsOpen in GitHub Copilot app